11 SAUCES.
ONE OBSESSION.
Choice Pizza® is built around a single belief: the sauce is the soul. Explore 11 handcrafted sauces on a pizza built exactly to your craving.
We built a compass
for your cravings.
Choice Pizza® isn't just about topping combinations. It's about precision. Our Flavor Compass helps you navigate our 11 signature sauces to find exactly what you're in the mood for.
FIND YOUR FAVORITE.
Every sauce is a different story. Which one's yours?
Classic Red
Slow-simmered San Marzano tomatoes with a secret blend of traditional Italian spices.
Sweet Red
A lighter, brighter tomato sauce with a natural sweetness from sun-ripened vine tomatoes.
Sweet & Spicy
A complex blend of honey and red chili flakes that sets the stage for a flavor dance.
Zesty Italian
Infused with oregano, garlic, and a touch of red wine vinegar for a sharp, vibrant profile.
Jalapeño Heat
Crafted with fire-roasted jalapeños and a proprietary blend of capsaicin-rich peppers.
Creamy White
A rich reduction of heavy cream, parmesan, and a Hint of white pepper.
Pesto
A classic blend of fresh basil, pine nuts, and extra virgin olive oil.
Herb Blend
A sophisticated combination of rosemary, thyme, and oregano in a light oil base.
BBQ Base
Hickory-smoked tomatoes with molasses and a touch of bourbon flavor.
Garlic Butter
Pure melted butter infused with mountain-grown roasted garlic.
Buffalo Base
Aggressive cayenne heat balanced with a vinegar-forward tang.
Finish It... Or It Finishes You.
The Beast Pizza Challenge drops a full 24-inch monster in front of one person and starts a 30-minute clock. Finish it clean and you earn the shirt, the photo, and the spot on the wall.
Official Beast Challenge tee
Beat the clock and walk out with the shirt.
- 24-inch hand-tossed monster with a reinforced edge
- Choice of any house sauce and extra-heavy mozzarella blend
- Up to 3 toppings included, with extras available
- Approx. 8-10 lbs finished weight
- Solo challenge only. One person, one pizza, 30 minutes.
- You must finish the entire 24-inch Beast to win.
- Water only is allowed during the challenge.
- No outside help, no sharing, no refunds under any circumstance.
Winners leave with proof. If you fail, there is no refund and no prize.
- Official "I Conquered The Beast" winner shirt
- Photo added to the Wall of Fame
- Optional social media feature
YOUR PIZZA. YOUR RULES.
Choose Your Sauce
Pick from 11 signature sauces
Size & Crust
Personal, Medium, Large. Thin, Original, or Stuffed
Pile on Toppings
Premium toppings. Nothing pre-decided
Add-ons
Sides, drinks, dips
Done. Order.
One-click checkout. Fast delivery
VISIT US IN PITTSFIELD.
Choice Pizza® is now open in the heart of Maine. Experience our 11 signature sauces at our flagship location.
